a-ha – Train of Thought: The Commuter Animation That Came Before Take On Me

a-ha · 1986 · Hunting High and Low

Train of Thought

The second pencil-sketch video — except these drawings came first.

5 min readLast checked November 17, 2026Song Stories
Quick StoryA one-minute read

“Train of Thought” is a single from a-ha’s debut album Hunting High and Low. Released in Britain in March 1986, it reached number eight. Pål Waaktaar based the lyric on writers he was reading at the time: the Norwegian poet Gunvor Hofmo, the novelist Knut Hamsun and Fyodor Dostoevsky. The video follows a commuter through his day in black-and-white pencil animation. That animation began as Commuter, a student film Michael Patterson made at CalArts — and it was the inspiration for the animation in “Take On Me”. What many viewers saw as the sequel was, in fact, the original.

AlbumHunting High and Low (1985)
SingleMarch 24, 1986 (UK)
WriterPål Waaktaar
ProducerTony Mansfield (album version)
Video directorsCandace Reckinger, Michael Patterson
PeakUK No. 8
Keep reading — the full story
Official Music VideoYouTube · a-ha

Official music video (YouTube, a-ha). Played in YouTube’s official player.

03The Origin

A third UK top ten

Confirmed Fact

“Train of Thought” is a Waaktaar song from the debut album. The album version was produced by Tony Mansfield; the single used a remix by Alan Tarney and John Hudson.

Confirmed Fact

Released in Britain on March 24, 1986, it reached number eight — a-ha’s third top-ten single in a row there, after “Take On Me” and “The Sun Always Shines on T.V.”. It was not a pop hit in the US, though a 12-inch remix made the dance club chart.

Confirmed Fact

The single is said to have sold 500,000 copies worldwide. There was no US 7-inch, and the European release was limited.

04The Lyrics

Nordic existentialism on the morning train

Confirmed Fact

The lyric draws on writers Waaktaar loved at the time: the Norwegian poet Gunvor Hofmo, the Nobel-winning novelist Knut Hamsun and Fyodor Dostoevsky — all writers of loneliness, anxiety and people pushed to the edge.

Interpretation

“Train of thought” is an idiom, but here it is also a literal train: a man riding the same line through the same city every day while his mind refuses to stop. Bright synth-pop sits on top of some fairly heavy reading.

05Behind the Video

The blueprint for Take On Me

Confirmed Fact

The video was directed by Candace Reckinger and Michael Patterson, the animators behind “Take On Me”.

Confirmed Fact

Its black-and-white pencil animation predates “Take On Me”. It began as Commuter, Patterson’s student film at the California Institute of the Arts, and it was the inspiration for the animation in the earlier hit.

Confirmed Fact

Most of the video is that older animated footage, cut with live-action shots of a-ha filmed during a break in their tour.

Reported Story

Commuter is said to have gone on to influence a generation of MTV videos.

Interpretation

In “Take On Me” the hero escapes the page. The commuter here never does: the same pencil line that opened a door in one video draws a closed, repeating routine in this one — which suits the lyric.

06The Context

Hand-drawn in the mid-eighties

Confirmed Fact

At the 1986 MTV Video Music Awards, a-ha won eight awards in one night, six of them for “Take On Me”. Hand-drawn animation mixed with live action had become their signature.

Interpretation

Two pencil-sketch videos in a row fixed an image of the band for a lot of viewers. But the drawings did not come from Japanese manga; they came from an American art-school film. Things that look alike can grow from very different places.

07POJV / Editor’s Note

A Japanese Listener’s Perspective

Manga-style video, round two!

Watching it back then, I honestly wondered if a-ha were fans of Japan.

A personal note from our Japanese editor: one listener’s reaction, not a statement of fact.

08Listen Again

Three things to listen for

  1. 1The synth rhythm that never lets up — the train of the title, still running.
  2. 2The gap between the bright tune and the dark words. Think of Waaktaar’s bookshelf and it sounds different.
  3. 3Harket holding back: no “Take On Me” climb here, a more restrained vocal.

These links open the official track pages on Spotify and Apple Music.

10Sources

* Cited through a secondary source; we have not read the original ourselves.